Irene de la Cruz finds a crack in AI capability that shines a light on human experience and judgement.
Would I have the judgement I have today if AI had built my first models at BCG?
Last week I spent a day at the beautiful BCG offices in Berlin, at an event co-organized by The Strategic Management Society and Boston Consulting Group (BCG), with strategy academics and practitioners exploring how the role of strategists is evolving in the context of AI.
I left with many reflections and insights. But there’s one challenge I can’t stop thinking about.
AI has made analysis quick and easy to produce. Models made in minutes, clear structure, polished charts.
The bottleneck is no longer the analysis, it’s judgement.
We used to learn judgement through exposure, building models line by line, designing the logic, making mistakes, being challenged by more experienced people. A slow and painstaking process, but it’s required to develop the intuition and taste that good judgement requires.
If AI now does most of the groundwork, how does the next generation build their judgement? And who is teaching it? Neither companies nor business schools have typically focused on this. Many people in the room confirmed they already see this issue in practice.
And there’s a twist. In the hands of someone with experience and judgement, AI is an amplifier. So the gap between senior people and juniors doesn’t shrink, it widens.
I’m left with these questions:
– What is the test for good judgement? How do we know if someone has it?
– How can companies make sure their future leaders build the skills that used to come “automatically” with time and experience?
And the most fundamental one: can judgement actually be trained rather than earned with time? If so, how?
