Improve Your Case Interview Questions

Blog

Improve Your Case Interview Questions

Chang Liu San Francisco, CA MBA, Kellogg McKinsey&Co Shell Canada The Case Room Umbrex member
Thought Leadership

Chang Liu explains what a good clarifying question in a case interview is and two that you should avoid. 

Two kinds of clarifying questions made me lose interest in a case interview within the first minute.

The first kind asks for data. “What’s the market size?” “How fast is revenue growing?”

Fair questions, but not clarifying ones. The interviewer will usually give you that data later, or expect you to estimate it. Asking for it up front sounds like you want someone else to do the work.

The second kind is canned. “What’s the goal, and what’s the timeline?”

I heard it in almost every interview, and it always sounded rehearsed. Most of the time (not always) the goal is already clear from the prompt, and the timeline is as soon as possible. If you genuinely aren’t sure, don’t ask. State an assumption and keep going: “I’m assuming they want to improve margins as quickly as possible.”

So what does a good clarifying question sound like? It asks how the business works.

Take a case where a home cleaning company’s profits have fallen. One question changes everything: “Do they employ the cleaners themselves, or do they franchise the brand and collect a fee from local owners?”

If they employ the cleaners, profit lives in wages, travel time between homes, and how full each cleaner’s day is. If they franchise, they earn a royalty on each franchisee’s sales. Same prompt, two completely different businesses.

That’s what I was listening for. Not a checklist, but whether you understood the business before trying to solve its problem.

Three habits:

  1. Ask how the client makes money: who pays, for what, and through which channel.

  2. Don’t ask for data you’ll be given later, and skip “what’s the goal and timeline?”

  3. Say why you’re asking: “I’m asking because it changes where the profit problem could be.”

 

Read the post on LinkedIn.